Common Myths About Keycaps, Profiles & Sound Signatures I Stopped Believing
When I first dipped my toes into the world of mechanical keyboards, I was bombarded with a plethora of myths and misconceptions. Some of them were so deeply ingrained in the community that it felt almost sacrilegious to question them. But as I’ve spent more time at my workbench, dissecting different keycap materials, profiles, and sound signatures, I’ve come to realize that many of these so-called “truths” are just that—myths. Let me share some of the most common misconceptions I’ve encountered and why I’ve chosen to leave them behind.
Myth #1: ABS Keycaps Are Always Inferior to PBT Keycaps
This is perhaps one of the most prevalent beliefs out there. While it’s true that PBT (Polybutylene Terephthalate) keycaps tend to be more durable and resistant to shine over time compared to ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene), it doesn't mean that all ABS keycaps are bad.
In fact, I’ve had some fantastic experiences with high-quality ABS keycaps, especially when they are double-shot molded. For instance, the Corsair K95 RGB comes with double-shot ABS keycaps that have held up remarkably well over time, providing a satisfying typing experience without any noticeable degradation.
| Keycap Material | Durability | Sound Signature | Price Range (USD) |
|---|---|---|---|
| ABS | Medium | Higher pitch | $20 - $100 |
| PBT | High | Lower pitch | $30 - $150 |
| Polycarbonate | Medium | Balanced | $25 - $120 |
Myth #2: Higher Profile Keycaps Are Always Better for Typing
I remember when I first started using Cherry profile keycaps, which are relatively tall. I was convinced that this height would improve my typing accuracy. However, after trying different profiles such as SA, DSA, and even the shorter OEM profile, I realized that personal comfort and preference play a more significant role than height alone. For example, I found myself loving the uniformity of DSA keycaps, which allowed for a lower profile and a more comfortable wrist angle. The comfort of your hand position often outweighs the perceived benefits of a taller profile.| Keycap Profile | Height | Typing Comfort | Notable Brands |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cherry | Medium | Good | Filco, Ducky |
| SA | Tall | Variable | Signature Plastics |
| DSA | Short | Excellent | Keycaps.com |
Myth #3: Sound Signature Is All About the Switch
While the type of switch does play a significant role in the overall sound signature of your keyboard, keycaps can dramatically alter the acoustics as well. I used to think that the only thing that mattered was the switch brand and type, but after modding a few of my boards, I discovered that the material and profile of the keycaps can either dampen or enhance the sound. For instance, I swapped out my Cherry MX Blue switches with PBT DSA keycaps, and the result was a deeper, more satisfying thock as opposed to the higher-pitched click I’d experienced before. This made me reconsider my approach to sound signatures—a holistic view is necessary for achieving the perfect auditory experience.| Switch Type | Sound Signature | Keycap Impact | Example Keycap Set |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linear | Smooth | Dampens | GMK |
| Tactile | Thock | Enhances | ABS/Polycarbonate |
| Clicky | Sharp | Varies | Cherry |